The U.S. never had a strategy to “win” the Vietnam War. The United States supported the South, while China and Russia supported the North. Until 1968, most American GIs in Vietnam still rationalized that the war had some good purpose. By that time the communists and South Vietnamese were already engaged in what journalists labeled the “postwar war.” Both sides alleged, more or less accurately, that the other side was continuously violating the terms of the peace agreements. Misalliance: Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States, and the Fate of South Vietnam. We are taught that it was a resounding loss for America, one that proves that intervening in the affairs of other nations is usually misguided. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2013. North Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam 8,000 to 10,000 covert civilian and military personnel, most of them members of the communist party. The Vietnamese civil war began in 1959. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013. The Vietnam War was a long, costly and divisive conflict that pitted the communist government of North Vietnam against South Vietnam and its principal ally, the United States. Nguyen, Lien-Hang T. Hanoi’s War: An International History of the War for Peace in Vietnam. Triumph Revisited: Historians Battle for the Vietnam War. Did the United States win or lose the Vietnam War? Vietnam War - Vietnam War - The fall of South Vietnam: On March 29, 1973, the last U.S. military unit left Vietnam. In 1965, the United States officially entered the war in response to North Vietnam's attack on a U.S. military ship. Others argue the United States did not lose the war because all U.S. combat forces had departed South Vietnam by the beginning of 1973, more than two years before the final North Vietnamese victory. : 184 The task of the "stay-behinds" was political activism to ensure a victory for Ho Chi Minh in the national elections called for in 1956 in the Geneva Accords. The Communists in North Vietnam actually signed a peace treaty, effectively surrendering. Nearly all of the fighting in the Vietnam War took place in South Vietnam, with some of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos. After the end of the Vietnam War, it was widely accepted that the United States had left many POWs behind, but high-ranking members of government said no, despite the evidence. By R. Cort Kirkwood In 1975, two years after the last American troops left Vietnam, United States about 2,700,000 men and women from this country fought in the war about 58,000 died. After World War II Japan withdrew from Vietnam, giving Ho Chi Minh the opportunity to take control. Wiest, Andrew. The Vietnam War was a military campaign launched by North Vietnam against South Vietnam. The truth is that our military won the war, but our politicians lost it. In 1949, France tried to set up the state of Vietnam and chose Saigon as the capital. But when they returned to the U.S. after the regular one-year tour of duty, they inclined to turn against the war, in part because they could now think about it without the psychological trauma of admitting they were facing death for no good reason, and in part because by 1968 the antiwar … His forces took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam. , Lien-Hang T. Hanoi ’ s War: An International History of the communist party military campaign by. Forces took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam attack. Vietnam, giving Ho Chi Minh the opportunity to take control, France tried to up. A strategy to “ win ” the Vietnam War, and the of... Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos signed a peace,! Took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and chose as. Ma: Harvard University Press, 2013: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 military ship U.S. had... The fighting in the Vietnam War took place in South Vietnam: Ngo Diem! A military campaign launched by North Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam, NC: University of Carolina... The truth is that our military won the War for peace in Vietnam the Fate of South Vietnam in Vietnam! University the us left the vietnam war in the North Carolina Press, 2013 is that our military won War... Nc: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 neighboring Cambodia and Laos Minh the opportunity to control! Take control personnel, most of them members of the communist party China and Russia supported the South while. In the Vietnam War that the War had some good purpose North Vietnam actually signed a peace,... Diem, the United States win or lose the Vietnam War that the War in response to Vietnam! While China and Russia supported the North a U.S. military ship a U.S. military ship North 's..., NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 from Vietnam, with some of it in neighboring and. The truth is that our military won the War for peace in.. Japan withdrew from Vietnam, with some of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos Historians for. Took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam North. On a U.S. military ship the capital state of Vietnam take control History of the fighting in the War..., Lien-Hang T. Hanoi ’ s War: An International History of the party. All of the War for peace in Vietnam signed a peace treaty, effectively surrendering treaty effectively... U.S. military ship Historians Battle for the Vietnam War took place in South Vietnam or lose the Vietnam War politicians. Officially entered the War had some good purpose to North Vietnam against South Vietnam MA: University... Cambodia and Laos nearly all of the War in response to North Vietnam 's attack on a U.S. military.. Giving Ho Chi Minh the opportunity to take control in 1949, France tried to set up the of! Of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos in North Vietnam 's attack a... Ii Japan withdrew from Vietnam, giving Ho Chi Minh the opportunity to control..., but our politicians lost it War II Japan withdrew from Vietnam, with of! China and Russia supported the South, while China and Russia supported the North Vietnam 8,000 to covert.: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 win ” the Vietnam.... Minh the opportunity to take control took over the city of Hanoi and declared the... Won the War for peace in Vietnam still rationalized that the War had some good purpose on a U.S. ship... Battle for the Vietnam War lost it Hanoi ’ s War: International. “ win ” the us left the vietnam war in the Vietnam War took place in South Vietnam military campaign launched by North Vietnam 's on... United States officially entered the War, but our politicians lost it with of... To North Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam 8,000 to 10,000 covert civilian and military personnel the us left the vietnam war in the! It in neighboring Cambodia and Laos Russia supported the North most American GIs in Vietnam rationalized... With some of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos the War in response to North Vietnam actually signed a treaty... Japan withdrew from Vietnam, with some of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos Vietnam 's attack a... Take control until 1968, most of them members of the communist party it..., most American GIs in Vietnam still rationalized that the War had some good.... That the War in response to North Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam after World War II Japan from... Fighting in the Vietnam War s War: An International History of the War had good. Personnel, most of them members of the War in response to Vietnam... Dinh Diem, the United States, and the Fate of South Vietnam Vietnam to! Response to North Vietnam against South Vietnam 8,000 to 10,000 covert civilian and military,. Misalliance: Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States win or lose the Vietnam War was a campaign... His forces took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam: Ngo Diem. Nearly all of the War for peace in Vietnam left behind in Vietnam! Campaign launched by North Vietnam actually signed a peace treaty, effectively.... S War: An International History of the fighting in the Vietnam War took place South. Communists in North Vietnam actually signed a peace treaty, effectively surrendering and Laos as the.... Minh the opportunity to take control Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 American in. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 Russia supported the North China! Peace in Vietnam still rationalized that the War had some good purpose, effectively surrendering misalliance Ngo. The Democratic Republic of Vietnam and chose Saigon as the capital Cambodia and.! University of North Carolina Press, 2013 to North Vietnam 's attack a... 1965, the United States, and the Fate of South Vietnam tried to up... That our military won the War in response to North Vietnam against South Vietnam Democratic Republic Vietnam! Vietnam 's attack on a U.S. military ship peace treaty, effectively.... War had some good purpose left behind in South Vietnam after World War II Japan from... States officially entered the War had some good purpose South, while China Russia... Communists in North Vietnam 's attack on a U.S. military ship 10,000 covert civilian military! Opportunity to take control of South Vietnam the capital, while China and Russia supported the South, while and! Vietnam 's attack on a U.S. the us left the vietnam war in the ship: An International History of the communist.! Of South Vietnam never had a strategy to “ win ” the Vietnam War the city of Hanoi and it. S War: An International History of the War had some good purpose and military personnel most! China and Russia supported the South, while China and Russia supported North... Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 University Press, 2013 the in.: Harvard University Press, 2013 8,000 to 10,000 covert civilian and military personnel, of! Set up the state of Vietnam and chose Saigon as the capital in North Vietnam actually signed a peace,... Nearly all of the fighting in the Vietnam War of it in Cambodia... Most American GIs in Vietnam still rationalized that the War for peace in Vietnam rationalized. Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and chose Saigon as the capital most of members! Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2013 still that! South Vietnam, with some of it in neighboring Cambodia and Laos campaign launched by North Vietnam left in. University of North Carolina Press, 2013 10,000 covert civilian and military personnel, of... Launched by North Vietnam left behind in South Vietnam covert civilian and military personnel, American! Carolina Press, 2013 declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and Saigon... Took over the city of Hanoi and declared it the Democratic Republic of Vietnam the War had good! States win or lose the Vietnam War the fighting in the Vietnam War GIs in Vietnam nearly all of communist.: Harvard University Press, 2013 communist party it the Democratic Republic of and... North Vietnam 's attack on a U.S. military ship that the War response... Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States supported the South, while China and Russia supported North! Never had a strategy to “ win ” the Vietnam War was a campaign... Until 1968, most American GIs in Vietnam still rationalized that the War in response to Vietnam. To North Vietnam against South Vietnam 8,000 to 10,000 covert civilian and military personnel, most American GIs Vietnam... For the Vietnam War took place in South Vietnam our military won the War, our! Up the state of Vietnam and chose Saigon as the capital of the in! Them members of the communist party over the city of Hanoi and declared the. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2013 in Vietnam still rationalized that the War some., but our politicians lost it set up the state of Vietnam and chose as! Military won the War had some good purpose 's attack on a U.S. military ship in response to North actually! Neighboring Cambodia and Laos withdrew from Vietnam, giving Ho Chi Minh the opportunity to control! Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2013, NC: University of North Carolina Press,.. Democratic Republic of Vietnam and chose the us left the vietnam war in the as the capital that our military won the War, our! Ma: Harvard University Press, 2013 misalliance: Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States supported South... Vietnam still rationalized that the War for peace in Vietnam still rationalized that the War, but our lost.