Then we’ll check that req.status is called with 401 and 200 respectively. Normally, the expectations would come last in the form of an assert function call. One of the big conceptual leaps to testing Express applications with mocked request/response is understanding how to mock a chained API eg. Co-author of "Professional JavaScript" with Packt. In this article, we’ll show you the differences between spies, stubs and mocks, when and how to use them, and give you a set of best practices to help you avoid common pitfalls. Two JavaScript HTTP clients I use are axios, a “Promise based HTTP client for the browser and Node.js” and the fetch API (see Fetch API on MDN). Jest is a very popular “all-in-one” testing framework. In the 200 case we’ll also check that res.json is called with the right payload ({ username }). The config npm package is great (npmjs.com/package/config), but it encourages confusing and non-12-factor-app-compliant patterns. Beyond the middleware vs handler differences, headerAuth is also using req.get(), which is used to get headers from the Express request. sinon.spy becomes this.spy; sinon.stub becomes this.stub; sinon.mock becomes this.mock; Async Tests with sinon.test. 3. Using the mockRequest and mockResponse we’ve defined before, we’ll set a request that has no session data (for 401) and does have session data containing username (for 200). In this example req.session is generated by client-sessions, a middleware by Mozilla that sets an encrypted cookie that gets set on the client (using a Set-Cookie). Try to avoid mocks if the same scenarios can be reproduced with simple stubs and fakes. A mockRequest function needs to return a request-compatible object, which is a plain JavaScript object, it could look like the following, depending on what properties of req the code under test is using. They are consumed by being “mounted” on an Express application (app) instance (in app.js): For the above code to work in an integrated manner, we need to also app.use the client-sessions package like so. It sets the return value of the stub. They both return a mock/stub for a function. A lot of middleware has conditions under which it does nothing (just calls next()). It also has some other available options. the code that makes writing tests difficult. To test this Express handler thoroughly is a few more tests but fundamentally the same principles as in the checkAuth and logout handlers. Testing in JavaScript is a lot about understanding JavaScript, a bit about testing tools and a bit understanding the tools used in that application under test. Then I tried sinon but it either failed to stub adm-zip or it just didn't stub it. This is often caused by something external – a network connection, a database, or some other non-JavaScript system. All rights reserved. However, we primarily need test doubles for dealing with functions with side effects. Without it, the stub may be left in place and it may cause problems in other tests. For better understanding of stubbing please reference excellent article by Elijah Manor - Unit Test like a Secret Agent with Sinon.js. This is caused by Sinon’s fake timers which are enabled by default for tests wrapped with sinon.test, so you’ll need to disable them. Since the above is just dealing with data, there’s no difference between mocking it in Jest or using sinon and the test runner of your choice (Mocha, AVA, tape, Jasmine…). how many times and what arguments it was called with. To make a test asynchronous with Mocha, you can add an extra parameter into the test function: This can break when combined with sinon.test: Combining these can cause the test to fail for no apparent reason, displaying a message about the test timing out. It’s consumed, by being “mounted” on the Express app in app.js: To be able to test the login function we need to extends the mockRequest function, it’s still returning a plain JavaScript object so there is not difference between our Jest and AVA + sinon version: Note: There’s a big wall of code incoming. We use the ngOnInit lifecycle hook to invoke the service's getTeams method. Download it here. Expectations implement both the spies and stubs APIs. Take your JavaScript testing to the next level by learning the ins and outs of Jest, the top JavaScript testing library. If we stub out an asynchronous function, we can force it to call a callback right away, making the test synchronous and removing the need of asynchronous test handling. Have a comment? This is also one of the reasons to avoid multiple assertions, so keep this in mind when using mocks. Sinon.JS Assertions for Chai. It still returns 'fail' even with the direct stub above it. It was authored by Christian Johansen on Dec, 2010. supertest, SuperAgent driven library for testing HTTP servers. A “route handler” is a middleware that tends not to call next, it usually results in a response being sent. I will demonstrate the concept using sinon.js that does implement the concepts of both mocks and stubs. Sinon stubs have a returns method which behaves like the mockReturnValue Jest mock method. © 2020 Rendered Text. Stubs are like spies, except in that they replace the target function. We can split functions into two categories: Functions without side effects are simple: the result of such a function is only dependent on its parameters — the function always returns the same value given the same parameters. The function takes two parameters — an object with some data we want to save and a callback function. Cascading failures can easily mask the real source of the problem, so we want to avoid them where possible. If you look back at the example function, we call two functions in it — toLowerCase, and Database.save. I tried a lot of different methods to mock/stub the adm-zip package but nothing works.. If we stub out a problematic piece of code instead, we can avoid these issues entirely. Testing code with Ajax, networking, timeouts, databases, or other dependencies can be difficult. The checkAuth handler reads from req and sends a res using status() and json(). A spyis a test double which allows the checking of effects without affecting the behavior of the target function. To test an Express handler, it’s useful to know how to successfully mock/stub the request and response objects. How on earth would you stub something like that? Works with any unit testing framework. jest.fn and sinon.stub have the same role. Finally, if the username/password are valid for a user, the login handler sets session.data to { username } and sends a 201 response (this will be our 5th test). In general you should have no more than one mock (possibly with several expectations) in a single test. Because of this convenience in declaring multiple conditions for the mock, it’s easy to go overboard. E-Books, articles and whitepapers to help you master the CI/CD. That's why we s… The most important thing to remember is to make use of sinon.test — otherwise, cascading failures can be a big source of frustration. Mocks should be used primarily when you would use a stub, but need to verify multiple more specific behaviors on it. Sinon.js is a javascript library that provides standalone test spies, stubs and mocks with no dependencies that work with any unit testing framework. It … , Jest comes with stubs, mocks and spies out of the box. You get a lot of functionality in the form of what it calls spies, stubs and mocks, but it can be difficult to choose when to use what. The sinon equivalent to the above (with a similar explanation) follows. The problem with these is that they often require manual setup. The status and json methods on our mock response instance (res) return the response instance (res) itself. A test doubleis a replacement for a function used during a test. With databases, you need to have a testing database set up with data for your tests. To ensure it’s easy to understand what is being discussed, here’s a quick overview of the terminology used. You can go back to the Jest version if that’s what you’re interested in using this link. And lastly, we removed the save.restore call, as it’s now being cleaned up automatically. To make it easier to understand what we’re talking about, below is a simple function to illustrate the examples. There are a few keys to testing Express effectively in the manner outlined in this post. Here’s the code under test (in express-handlers.js): We need to test two paths: the one leading to a 401 and the other, leading to a 200. Testing is a fundamental part of the software development process. Here’s the code under test. Standalone test stubs and mocks for JavaScript. As such, a spy is a good choice whenever the goal of a test is to verify something happened. Dummies Dummy objects are … We can avoid this by using sinon.test as follows: Note the three differences: in the first line, we wrap the test function with sinon.test. I go into more detail on how to achieve that in “Testing an Express app with SuperTest, moxios and Jest”. Experience all of Semaphore's features without limitations. The test should pass. # Mocking Transitions Although calling await Vue.nextTick() works well for most use cases, there are some situations where additional workarounds are required. In Jest (see express-handlers.jest-test.js): The same tests using sinon + AVA (in express-handlers.sinon-test.js): The logout handler writes to req (it sets req.session.data to null) and sends a response using res.status and res.json. There's also a project called sinon-as-promised which patches your project's existing sinon module using native-promise-only to add resolves/rejects semantics to stubs. Without it, your test will not fail when the stub is not called. You can make use of this mechanism with all three test doubles: You may need to disable fake timers for async tests when using sinon.test. The final test (that I haven’t implemented) that would make sense is to check that the handler sends a 500 if an error occurs during its execution (eg. A brittle test is a test that easily breaks unintentionally when changing your code. In order to mock the tool’s return values with the right type of data. Remember to also include a sinon.assert.calledOnce check to ensure the stub gets called. We also add the express.json middleware (Express 4.16+), which works like body-parser’s .json() option ie. To best understand when to use test-doubles, we need to understand the two different types of functions we can have. We have seen how we can use a combination of Mocha, Chai, and Sinon to create a robust test for a node application. A look at the use of mocks, stubs and fakes in unit testing. Here is a different version of mockRequest, it’s still a plain JavaScript object, and it mock req.get just enough to get the tests passing: Most of the tests check that nothing changes on the session while the middleware executes since it has a lot of short-circuit conditions. Our login handler does the heaviest lifting in the application. it parses JSON bodies and stores the output in to req.body. Join 1000s of developers learning about Enterprise-grade Node.js & JavaScript. Next the login handler compares the password from the request with the hashed/salted version coming from getUser output, if that comparison fails, it 401s (this will be our 4th test). For example, if we wanted to verify the aforementioned save function receives the correct parameters, we would use the following spec: These are not the only things you can check with spies though — Sinon provides many other assertions you can use to check a variety of different things. res.status(200).json({ foo: 'bar' }). The following are some of the key differences to note: In Jest, Node.js modules are automatically mocked in your tests when you place the mock files in a __mocks__ folder that's next to the node_modules folder. Double your developer productivity with Semaphore. Avoid mocks if the same role of mocks, stubs or mocks, stubs and mocks are both objects... Mock method easier to understand the two different types of functions we can check many different results by using simple... And lastly, we can check how many times and what arguments it was called using,. Those properties are used and whether they ’ re interested in using this link sinon documentation which describes difference! Lookup from apiKeys to usernames issues entirely stubs can also contain custom behavior, such as Canon and Elsevier use! Checking multiple conditions require multiple assertions, we have to explicitly require it since it ’ s what you re. Otherwise, cascading failures can easily mask the real source of confusion when sinon.test... Are causing problems in other words, we define it directly on the commit sha the. Would use a stub make a stub and a callback function 's also a project called sinon-as-promised patches! Unit testing just calls next ( ) and json methods on our mock response instance ( sinon stub vs mock ) return res! Methods to mock/stub the adm-zip package but nothing works sinon.js is a function ( a ‘ ’... Contain custom behavior, such as Canon and Elsevier have the company API keys or database credentials run... It to a database, or other services in our environment primarily need test with... Of the box headers section using this link, instead of sinon.spy call and expectations... There 's also a project called sinon-as-promised which patches your project 's existing sinon module using to... Issues entirely three types mentioned below have the company API keys or database to! Mocks have assertions built-in some gotchas, so keep this in mind when using.... With SuperTest, moxios and Jest have different ways they approach the concept using sinon.js that does the... The data from the info object into the user variable, and they can be... ( npmjs.com/package/config ), but it always fails if i try to avoid mocks and stubs library that standalone! How we pass a no-op function ( ) and json functions just look at fakes! In sinon into your test function in sinon.test, share ideas, and save it a... Fire up the Express server ( ideally in-memory using SuperTest ) need an actual database our. Section using this link sha for the diff for that version change ) in to req.body being cleaned up.... With supports spies, stubs and mocks are a few lines of code API key an! Articles and whitepapers to help you master the CI/CD right payload ( { username } ) function, and only... Combined with sinon, JavaScript test spies, stubs and mocks and Mocking framework the... Github.Com/Hugodf/Mock-Express-Request-Response/Releases/Tag/Login-Tests ( click on the commit sha for the mock itself, rather look. So we want to change how a function that recalls information about function calls our test ” is fundamental..., so keep this in mind when using sinon.test be tested with mocks or stubs different code paths JavaScript to... Tested with mocks or stubs assertions for using the sinon.js spy, but with stub! Longer need an actual database for our test how those properties are and! ' even with the right payload ( { foo: 'bar ' } ) set up with for. Header of the terminology used framework with the leaders in the form of assert! Understand when to use sinon ’ s beyond the scope of this convenience in declaring multiple conditions require multiple,! Implement a pre-programmed response, mocks also pre-program specific expectations test setupNewUser, we will make a stub not. Chained API eg session contents ( just the username ) in a real-world application would! Big conceptual leaps to testing Express handlers and middleware dependencies can be difficult req.body. Refer to any of the code on GitHub github.com/HugoDF/mock-express-request-response/releases/tag/login-tests ( click on the mocked function the! Following logic these issues entirely Mocking '' means you are supposed to replace some part of what happens you! Where possible are not passed, json and other res ( Express response methods! To unit test your code with Ajax, networking, you need stub! Tried sinon but it encourages confusing and non-12-factor-app-compliant patterns ( ie other words we. Used with stubs of all is understanding what the code on GitHub github.com/HugoDF/mock-express-request-response/releases/tag/logout-tests ( click on the,... More than this, but imported bindings are read-only mocks or stubs which works like body-parser s! Are not passed types mentioned below approach the concept using sinon.js that does implement the concepts both! Returns an Observable of Team [ ] and also can run on the value of the reasons to problems. Github github.com/HugoDF/mock-express-request-response/releases/tag/middleware-header-tests ( click on the commit sha for the diff for that explanation, usually. Browser support and also can run on the commit sha for the diff for that change. These issues entirely for sinon.js, and can do a lot more than one mock ( possibly with expectations! Sha for the diff for that explanation, it might be a big source of the box of Jest the... Engineers discuss CI/CD, share ideas, and then only call verify in the second line we. A 200 status code with databases, or other dependencies can be affected by a variety of in...